Filmography
| Year | Title | Role |
| 2025 | The Ritual (2025) | Father Theophilus Riesinger |
| 2025 | Modi: Three Days on the Wing of Madness (2025) | Maurice Gangnat |
| 2025 | Dead Man's Wire (2026) | M.L. Hall |
| 2023 | Knox Goes Away (2024) | Xavier Crane |
| 2021 | American Traitor: The Trial of Axis Sally (2021) | James Laughlin |
| 2021 | House of Gucci (2021) | Aldo Gucci |
| 2019 | Once Upon a Time in Hollywood | Marvin Schwarz |
| 2019 | The Irishman (2019) | Jimmy Hoffa |
| 2017 | Julian Schnabel: A Private Portrait | Self |
| 2017 | Hangman (2017) | Detective Archer |
| 2017 | The Pirates of Somalia | Seymour Tolbin |
| 2016 | Misconduct | Charles Abrams |
| 2015 | Danny Collins | Danny Collins |
| 2014 | The Humbling | Simon Axler |
| 2014 | Manglehorn | A.J. Manglehorn |
| 2013 | Salomé | King Herod |
| 2012 | Stand Up Guys | Val |
| 2011 | Jack and Jill | Self |
| 2011 | The Son of No One | Det. Stanford |
| 2011 | Wilde Salome | King Herod |
| 2010 | You Don't Know Jack | Jack Kevorkian |
| 2009 | I Knew It Was You: Rediscovering John Cazale | Actor |
| 2008 | Righteous Kill | Detective David Fisk |
| 2007 | 88 Minutes | Dr. Jack Gramm |
| 2007 | Ocean's Thirteen | Willy Bank |
| 2005 | Two for the Money | Walter Abrams |
| 2004 | William Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice | Shylock |
| 2003 | The Recruit | Walter Burke |
| 2003 | Gigli | Starkman |
| 2002 | Simone | Viktor Taransky |
| 2002 | People I Know | Eli Wurrman |
| 2000 | Chinese Coffee | Harry Levine |
| 1999 | The Insider | Lowell Bergman |
| 1999 | Any Given Sunday | Tony D'Amato |
| 1997 | Donnie Brasco | Lefty |
| 1997 | The Devil's Advocate | John Milton |
| 1996 | Looking for Richard | Richard III/Himself |
| 1996 | City Hall | John Pappas |
| 1995 | Heat (1995) | Lt. Vincent Hanna |
| 1993 | Carlito's Way | Carlito Brigante |
| 1992 | Glengarry Glen Ross | Ricky Roma |
| 1992 | Scent of a Woman | Lieutenant Colonel Frank Slade |
| 1991 | Frankie and Johnny (1991) | Johnny |
| 1990 | Dick Tracy | Big Boy Caprice |
| 1990 | The Local Stigmatic | Graham |
| 1990 | THE GODFATHER, Coda: The Death of Michael Corleone | Don Michael Corleone |
| 1989 | Sea of Love (1989) | Det. Frank Keller |
| 1985 | Revolution (1985) | Tom Dobb |
| 1983 | Scarface 40th Anniversary | Antonio "Tony" Montana |
| 1982 | Author! Author! | Ivan Travalian |
| 1980 | Cruising | Steve Burns |
| 1979 | ...And Justice for All | Arthur Kirkland |
| 1977 | Bobby Deerfield | Bobby |
| 1975 | Dog Day Afternoon | Sonny Wortzik |
| 1974 | The Godfather, Part II (1975) | Michael Corleone |
| 1973 | Serpico | Serpico |
| 1973 | Scarecrow (1920) | Francis Lionel `'Lion'` Delbuchi |
| 1972 | The Godfather | Michael Corleone |
| 1971 | Panic in Needle Park | Bobby |
